Since the Soviet victory over Nazi Germany in 1945, May 9th has had a special place in Russian hearts. Just like with the U.S. and Western Europe’s victory in World War II, the victory over Nazi Germany was a spectacular achievement. Since that year the Soviet Union and now Russia have used the May 9th parade to showcase Russian military might. It has had a twofold purpose. The first is demonstrate to the world Russian military might and technological prowess. From Stalin to Khrushchev and Brezhnev, the Mayday parade was a direct threat to Western powers. The second reason was to keep the Russian populace in check. Among other celebrations and events, it reminds the Russian people that they are aways in danger of being invaded. And if any dissidents had nefarious thoughts, the mighty Russian military would quash them. Vladimir Putin has certainly used May 9th in the same way as his Soviet predecessors.
But this May 9th, 2022 has taken new significance for Russia. Not since their invasion of Afghanistan 1979 has May 9th had such implications. Russia’s disastrous invasion of Afghanistan was partially responsible for the collapse of the Soviet Union. No one remembers that more than a then mid-level KGB officer. He literally lost his advancement and livelihood along with millions of Russians. The May 9th parade, among so many other things, lost it’s punch. The Chechan wars, Georgia (South Ossetia), Syria, Crimea and Donbass illustrated the both shortcomings and victories of the Russian military.
2022 has certainly been a different year for Russia. Beset by failures in their invasion of Ukraine, NATO was concerned that Putin would try extreme measures to achieve some level of success by May 9th. The Russian military did step up their military operations and bombardments but as of writing no extreme measures nor reserve/conscript call-ups have occurred. Putin tried to put a brave face by parading his army and blaming the West for Russia’s ills. But the fact that Putin held a parade is exactly why he has nothing to celebrate.
To understand, let’s go back a bit. The 1967 Arab-Israeli war saw Israel pummel the Egyptian army and take the Sinai Peninsula. Several Egyptian Generals realized that they lost because of their emphasis on military parades. While Israel’s forces trained for combat, Egyptian forces practiced months for military parades. As impressive as they were, these parades had the opposite effect than intended. The Egyptian military spent money on uniforms, equipment and fuel to get soldiers and vehicles moving in lock step. But that sapped their resources and training for actual fighting. Thus, in 1967, the outnumbered Israeli Defense Forces won the day. In preparations for the 1973 Yom Kippur war the Egyptians correctly ditched formalities and focused on training and equipping for war. Their initial gains were spectacular and if not for the Egyptian high brass dismissing their top general to push too far ahead Israel may not have survived.
And that is the paradox that Vladimir Putin faces. He needs the parade to project Russian military power to the world. And it keeps the Russian people sufficiently cowed to avoid a coup d’etat. But, it prevents his army from actually preparing for war. In the middle of a war they are losing. It looks impressive to show ranks of stout Russian soldiers and nuclear capable mobile missile launchers. But, it does little to actually help Russia win their faltering invasion of Ukraine. Will Putin change course. Probably not. He is stuck both needing to keep and to eliminate the May 9th parade. There are numerous other factors that will determine the fate of Ukraine and Russia. How the Russian military’s penchant for pomp and circumstance influences the outcome will be a point of interest.


